Mostly done with Szczecin

In the last two months I spent quite a lot of time working on a data import into OpenStreetMap that has been a little different from most of the imports happening in the project.  I’m quite happy with the result but I’m also really happy to be done with in.

Most of Poland administrative institutions today are behind in the aspect of sharing information with others for common good, and information re-use (and in many other aspects).  This includes geospatial data and clinging on to it and always assuming there might be something secret in it, such as… I don’t know, really.  Obviously at some level there can be information protected by the privacy laws intermixed with geospatial data (parcel owners etc.), the other common case of spatial data that cannot be shared is the locations of protected species.  But most of the time none of this is concerned.

Then there are laws in place that mandate those institutions to take money for disclosing particular types of information, and only under rather restrictive licensing conditions (nothing that remotely resembles CC-By-SA).  But according to some people in the know, there are other laws in Poland that make most of this information classify as public information.  Theoretically those former laws take precedence over the public information related ones, but last I heard there’s some other legal complication, way above my level of understanding law (unfortunately), that in effect means there’s a conflict/inconsistency in that system.  What this means is that the institutions can assume either interpretation and they should be safe under the law.  But they will always assume the “closed” interpretation.

So looking at all the other places and “battles” that people in OpenStreetMap have with their local administrations, it seems that this is a common trace in Europe, with a slowly progressing change in the direction of openness.  But perhaps if you drew a little map of how “open” the institutions in different places are based on the number of data releases that happened, the area covered by Poland would mostly range between black and dark grey.  So it was a lucky strike that the city of Szczecin was happy to let us use all the information available through their GIS website, including for automatic processing.

Their website has bitmap layers with some pretty high quality data, and no vector data available directly.  This meant that it could be manually copied or some complex and rather hacky vectorisation could be attempted (obviously talking only about the data layers that were lacking in OpenStreetMap, not just everything — if you’ve done any OSMing, you know that some types of data are unlikely to be crowdsourced).  French mappers are trying to manually copy the national cadastre bitmap layer made available by their administration, but it seems like a very tedious work, which is unlikely to be finished soon.  So I tried to automate as much as possible of the vectorisation and I think in a big part it was a success.  Still quite a lot of manual work was left to be done.  Not a very interesting job, but not one that you can let some monkeys do for you either, because everything that could be automated has already been automated.  So I’m really happy that it’s mostly done now (import status page firefox only, and takes a while to load).  More details in Polish available in this post, but check out the mapsurfer screenshots and the tree density heat-map there.  Maybe I’ll have a lightning talk about it at the upcoming State Of the Map 2010.

We’ve contacted some other municipalities trying hard not to scare them with the modern terms like share-alike etc., and as expected they are reluctant, but there seem to be two more candidates right now, and the import process is better streamlined now, and it really could be quite straight forward if it was not for some little annoying properties of the way the Szczecin data was shared.

For the moment I have a long backlog of information surveyed in my own neighbourhood to put on the map.

One Response to “Mostly done with Szczecin”

  1. football video games online Says:

    What a material of un-ambiguity and preserveness
    of valuable experience on the topic of unpredicted

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: